attorneys for 42-year-old david serbeck on monday told the utah court of appeals that serbeck 's original lawyers should have pushed harder to exclude or dispute allegations tying his 2007 relationship with the 17-year-old victim to his shooting .
two years after he had sex with the 17-year-old , serbeck was shot and paralyzed in july 2009 by reginald campos , who suspected serbeck of aggressively following his daughter in an suv while patrolling their buffdale neighborhood .
campos ' daughter and the 17-year-old victim were not the same girl .